Community » Get Advice » Exercise and Fitness » leg extensions versus lunges

Post: Post a New Reply  |  Start a New Topic in this Category
leg extensions versus lunges : Community Message Boards
 AuthorTitle / Message Body
Starving2Death Starving2Death
Sun, Jun 6, 2010 15:06
 Unrated
leg extensions versus lunges
I've had continuing problems with my knees and have omitted lunges and squats from my routine. In lieu of that , I regulary perform leg extensions and leg curls. Can I still achieve a tone sculpted leggy look?

Also, I am working on a firmer, rounder butt. It seems that all the glutes exercises are about contracting either the maximus or minimus with the exception of squats which seem to do something else to the muscle. Can you clarify or diferentiate all this for me, please? Mass building, toning, or stretching?

lelogosdemoi lelogosdemoi
Charlotte NC
Tue, Jun 8, 2010 11:06
 Unrated
knees and butt
Leg extensions are much much worse on your knees than lunges or squats. I don't think leg extensions are nearly as bad for knees but they aren't the most effective way to work your hamstrings. What kind of trouble do you have with your knees? Where is the pain and when do you get it? Are you a runner?

I've noticed that when I am doing heavy high-rep (12-15) sets of step ups and bulgarian split squats for several consequtive weeks I do begin to experience some pain during the exersize on the inside of my knee. Taking a week off has always resolved that. I do not ever have trouble with squats or regular lunges. I have been training step up differently lately - lighter weight and focusing on pushing up thru the heel on the step w/o leaning forward and pulling up from the active glute - not using momentum or hamstring. That has really helped correct my form, strengthen glutes and stabilize my neds. I also have been doing overhead squats lately instead of standard barbell across the shoulders and have been squating all the way down, ass-to-grass aka A2G (butt to the floor) for full range of motion thru the knees and that has helped strengthen my knees also - and it's killer intense on glutes. It's good to vary the types of squats that you're doing every 4-6 weeks so that you hit the muscle in new ways and avoid inflaming joints from too much repetition.

I recommend you add deadlifts - they will strengthen your hamstrings, lower back, and glutes.

You might also try some different variations of static lunges - front foot elevated on a step, back foot elevated on a step. You can also do side-to-side lunges.

My advice is, if you're having severe sharp pain in your knees, take a week off totally and ice them. Then when you go back, do body weight only on squats and lunges and do full A2G squats- using the full motion of the knee will put LESS stress on it than partial motion, and will strengthen all the muscles supporting the knee. And, add in deadlifts- if you've never done them before I'd recommend starting with straight-leg (Romanian) with just the 45-lb bar - 2-3 sets of 10-12.

A2G squats, barbell deadlifts, and Bulgarian split squats are the best 3 exercises for a round butt and shapely legs. Leg machines won't get you there.

lelogosdemoi lelogosdemoi
Charlotte NC
Thu, Jun 10, 2010 11:06
 Unrated
correction
Sorry, I meant: I don't think LEG CURLS are nearly as bad for knees but they aren't the most effective way to work your hamstrings.

RobertGarrett RobertGarrett
Fri, Oct 15, 2021 14:10
 Unrated
I'm the absolute first in the club! Get some information about any game or any tangle, I'll tell you. Snickers. I have such an encounter that you can give out milk for hurt. Today I http://www.savagecycles.ca/ Luxury Casino will say that the coolest web-based gambling club is. Here I hang out the entirety of my leisure time, sorry for the time, not however much I might want.

Topic Rating: 
  • Delicious

Follow Us

Explore FitClick
Browse this section for quick links to our calorie counter and other popular diet and fitness features. From diet plans to weight loss programs, FitClick has the content you need to lead a healthy life. Find workout routines, a calorie calculator and more at your source for diet and fitness information.
We have updated our Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018. We have done this in preparation for the EU's new data privacy law, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Please take the time to review our updated documentation by clicking on the Privacy Policy link at the bottom of this page. By continuing to use this service on or after May 25, 2018, you agree to our updated Privacy Policy.